360 Degree Feedback: Definition, Research and Conditions for Use


360 degree feedback is a development process in which a person rates their own behavior at work and receives anonymous ratings of the same behaviors from the people around them, usually a manager, peers and direct reports. It is also called 360 feedback, multisource feedback or multi rater feedback. The report compares the self rating with the ratings of each group, and the gaps between them become the material for a development conversation. This guide gives the definition, summarizes what research finds about accuracy and results, and sets out the conditions under which 360 degree feedback is useful for a leader.
What Is 360 Degree Feedback?
In a 360 degree feedback process, several groups of raters answer the same questionnaire about one person. Each group sees that person from a different position:
- Self. The leader rates their own behavior. This rating is the reference point for every comparison in the report.
- Manager. The manager sees results, priorities and how the leader handles pressure from above.
- Peers. Colleagues at the same level see cooperation, reliability and how the leader handles competing interests.
- Direct reports. Team members see daily leadership behavior: clarity, fairness, listening and follow through.
Ratings from peers and direct reports are grouped and reported as averages so that no single answer can be traced to a person. The practice has been formally labeled and used in organizations for more than 25 years (Bracken, Rose, and Church, 2016). The glossary entry on 360 feedback gives a short definition.
How a 360 Degree Feedback Process Works
- Purpose. The organizer states what the feedback is for and who will see the report. This guide covers developmental use, where the report is shared between the leader and a coach or facilitator.
- Rater selection. The leader chooses people who work with them regularly and see them in different situations.
- Collection. The leader and the raters complete the same questionnaire. Answers from raters are anonymous.
- Report. Results are aggregated by rater group and set beside the self rating.
- Debrief. The leader reviews the report, ideally with a coach, and decides which one or two gaps deserve attention.
- Goals and follow up. The leader sets specific goals, tells raters what they are working on, and reviews progress after several months.
Self Ratings and Ratings From Others
The central idea of 360 degree feedback is that people do not see themselves as others see them. Meta analytic research supports this. Harris and Schaubroeck (1988) found a relatively high correlation between peer and supervisor ratings (.62) and only moderate correlations between self and supervisor ratings (.35) and between self and peer ratings (.36). Conway and Huffcutt (1997) found low mean correlations between self ratings and ratings from supervisors (.22) and peers (.19).
The same research shows that raters within one group also differ. Conway and Huffcutt (1997) report mean reliabilities of .30 for subordinates, .37 for peers and .50 for supervisors, and conclude that the different sources had somewhat different perspectives on performance. Two practical points follow. One rater is a weak basis for a conclusion, so reports rely on averages across several raters. A difference between groups can carry information, because a manager and a direct report observe different behavior.
Research Findings on 360 Degree Feedback Results
- Average improvement is small. Smither, London and Reilly (2005) analyzed 24 longitudinal studies. Improvement in direct report, peer and supervisor ratings over time was generally small. Their review also reports that multisource ratings are related to other measures of leadership effectiveness.
- Feedback can lower performance. Across 607 effect sizes and 23,663 observations, Kluger and DeNisi (1996) found that feedback interventions improved performance on average (d = .41), and that more than one third of them decreased it. Feedback was less effective as attention moved toward the self and away from the task.
- Unfavorable ratings are often discounted. Brett and Atwater (2001) found that less favorable ratings were related to negative reactions and to beliefs that the feedback was less accurate. Recipients who saw the feedback as less accurate also saw it as less useful. The authors conclude that their results question the assumption that negative and discrepant feedback motivates positive change.
- Coaching adds a small gain. Smither and colleagues (2003) followed 1,361 senior managers who received multisource feedback, 404 of whom worked with an executive coach. Managers who worked with a coach were more likely to set specific goals (d = .16) and to ask their supervisors for ideas for improvement (d = .36). They improved more than other managers in direct report and supervisor ratings, with a small effect size (d = .17).
These findings describe a tool whose results depend on what happens after the report is delivered.
Conditions That Make 360 Degree Feedback Useful
Smither, London and Reilly (2005) propose that improvement is most likely when feedback indicates that change is necessary and when recipients have a positive feedback orientation, perceive a need to change, react positively, believe change is feasible, set appropriate goals, and take actions that lead to skill and performance improvement. Combined with the other studies above, this points to six working conditions:
- A developmental purpose stated in advance. Raters and recipients need to know how the report will be used before anyone answers.
- Protected anonymity. Candid answers depend on raters trusting that individual responses stay hidden. A minimum number of raters per group is the usual safeguard.
- Questions about observable behavior. Given the Kluger and DeNisi finding, feedback about what a person does is more usable than feedback about what kind of person they are.
- A guided debrief. A coach helps the leader read unfavorable results without dismissing them, which is the reaction Brett and Atwater describe. See these coaching debrief questions for the structure of that conversation.
- One or two specific goals. Specific goals are the first measurable difference in the coaching study by Smither and colleagues (2003).
- Follow up with raters. Asking for ideas, sharing goals and checking progress turn a report into a process.
Common Problems With 360 Degree Feedback
- Mixed purposes. When the same ratings feed development and pay or promotion decisions, raters have reasons to adjust their answers.
- Too few raters. Small groups weaken both anonymity and the reliability of averages.
- A report with no conversation. A leader left alone with unfavorable numbers tends to question their accuracy.
- Too many priorities. A long list of gaps produces no clear goal.
- Low trust. In a team where people fear consequences for candor, ratings drift toward safe answers. Psychological safety is a precondition for honest upward feedback.
360 Degree Feedback Example
A director of operations completes a 360 with her manager, four peers and five direct reports. She rates herself high on consulting others before decisions. Her manager agrees. Her peers rate her lower, and their comments mention decisions announced in meetings without prior discussion. Her direct reports rate her close to her own score.
In the debrief, her coach asks which decisions the peers are likely to have in mind. She identifies two budget changes that affected other departments. She sets one goal: before any decision that changes another unit's resources, she will speak with the two peers most affected. She tells her peers about the goal and asks them for one suggestion each. Six months later she asks the same peers how the last three decisions were handled.
360 Degree Feedback and Political Skill
Political skill is defined by Ferris and colleagues as the ability to understand others at work and to use that knowledge to influence them toward personal and organizational objectives (Ferris et al., 2005). Much of it concerns how a person is perceived: whether colleagues see them as sincere, whether their reading of a situation matches what others observe, and whether their relationships are as strong as they believe. A leader has limited access to these perceptions without asking. For that reason a self report measure and ratings from colleagues complement each other on this topic. See the guides to political skill and the Political Skill Inventory.
How Pine Perspective Uses 360 Degree Feedback
Pine Perspective measures what a leader can do. Its Influence Agility assessment starts with a self assessment on three dimensions: Landscape Reading, Relationship Navigation and Projected Authenticity. The 360 degree feedback option combines that self assessment with anonymous feedback from up to 7 colleagues and shows how others perceive a leader's influence style compared with the leader's own view.
Individual responses are never shown. Only aggregated results are reported, and a minimum of 3 respondents per category is required so that no individual can be identified. The process is available exclusively through certified Pine coaches, who guide the leader through setup, collection and interpretation. The method is described on the political skill assessment page, and the coach offering on the page for coaches.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is 360 degree feedback? 360 degree feedback is a process in which a person rates their own behavior at work and receives anonymous ratings of the same behaviors from a manager, peers and direct reports. The report compares the self rating with the ratings of each group.
Does 360 degree feedback improve performance? On average the improvement is small. A meta analysis of 24 longitudinal studies found generally small improvement in direct report, peer and supervisor ratings over time, with more improvement when recipients see a need to change, react positively, set goals and take action (Smither, London, and Reilly, 2005).
Is 360 degree feedback anonymous? Ratings are normally reported as group averages, with a minimum number of raters per group so that no single answer can be traced to a person. Candid answers depend on that protection.
How accurate are self ratings compared with ratings from others? Agreement is moderate at best. One meta analysis reports correlations of .35 between self and supervisor ratings and .36 between self and peer ratings, against .62 between peers and supervisors (Harris and Schaubroeck, 1988).
Does a coach make 360 degree feedback more effective? In a study of 1,361 senior managers, those who reviewed their feedback with an executive coach set more specific goals and improved slightly more in direct report and supervisor ratings one year later (Smither et al., 2003).
References
- Bracken, D. W., Rose, D. S., & Church, A. H. (2016). The evolution and devolution of 360° feedback. Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 9(4), 761 to 794.
- Brett, J. F., & Atwater, L. E. (2001). 360° feedback: Accuracy, reactions, and perceptions of usefulness. Journal of Applied Psychology, 86(5), 930 to 942.
- Conway, J. M., & Huffcutt, A. I. (1997). Psychometric properties of multisource performance ratings: A meta-analysis of subordinate, supervisor, peer, and self-ratings. Human Performance, 10(4), 331 to 360.
- Ferris, G. R., Treadway, D. C., Kolodinsky, R. W., Hochwarter, W. A., Kacmar, C. J., Douglas, C., & Frink, D. D. (2005). Development and validation of the political skill inventory. Journal of Management, 31(1), 126 to 152.
- Harris, M. M., & Schaubroeck, J. (1988). A meta-analysis of self-supervisor, self-peer, and peer-supervisor ratings. Personnel Psychology, 41(1), 43 to 62.
- Kluger, A. N., & DeNisi, A. (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254 to 284.
- Smither, J. W., London, M., Flautt, R., Vargas, Y., & Kucine, I. (2003). Can working with an executive coach improve multisource feedback ratings over time? A quasi-experimental field study. Personnel Psychology, 56(1), 23 to 44.
- Smither, J. W., London, M., & Reilly, R. R. (2005). Does performance improve following multisource feedback? A theoretical model, meta-analysis, and review of empirical findings. Personnel Psychology, 58(1), 33 to 66.
Share this article

Founder & CEO, Pine Perspective
Andrea Gill is the Founder and CEO of Pine Perspective, specializing in influence agility and leadership development. With over a decade of experience at the intersection of organizational behavior, strategy, and ethics, she helps leaders develop the political skill their careers actually run on.
You might also like

Psychological Safety at Work: Definition, Research and Leader Practices
Psychological safety at work: Edmondson's definition, research on team learning and speaking up, signs of low safety, and how leaders build it.


DISC Styles and Influence at Work
How each DISC style (D, I, S, C) influences at work, its common blind spot, how to widen your range, and how to influence colleagues of each style.


Office Politics for Introverts: How Quiet Professionals Build Influence at Work
Office politics for introverts: political skill is only moderately related to extraversion. Strengths, challenges and practical ways to build influence.
