Executive Presence: Meaning, Research and How to Develop It


Executive presence is the impression a leader makes on others that leads them to see that leader as credible, confident and ready for greater responsibility. It is a perception held by an audience. It forms quickly from how a person acts, speaks and appears, and it is confirmed or revised by what that person does over time. This guide explains the meaning of executive presence, summarizes research on how such impressions form, and sets out ways to develop executive presence that rest on evidence.
What Is Executive Presence?
The term comes from practice. Coaches, recruiters and promotion committees use it to describe whether a person appears ready for a senior role. Academic research on the term itself is limited. In one of the few peer reviewed studies, Dagley and Gaskin (2014) interviewed 34 business professionals with expertise in the effectiveness of executives. They suggest that a person with executive presence is someone who, by virtue of how they are perceived by audience members at any given point in time, exerts influence beyond that conferred through formal authority.
Two features of that definition matter in practice. Presence depends on the audience, so the same person can be seen differently by two groups. Presence also changes with time, because people revise their view as they observe more. The glossary entry on executive presence gives a short definition.
Gravitas, Communication and Appearance
The most cited popular source is Executive Presence: The Missing Link Between Merit and Success by Sylvia Ann Hewlett, published by HarperBusiness in 2014. Drawing on surveys conducted by the Center for Talent Innovation, Hewlett describes executive presence as a mix of three elements:
- Gravitas. Confidence under pressure and decisiveness. This element carries the most weight in her account.
- Communication. Speaking skills and the ability to read an audience.
- Appearance. Appearance acts mainly as a filter that can distract from the other two.
This model is a practitioner framework based on survey responses. It is a useful vocabulary for a coaching conversation, and it should be read beside the research below.
Research Findings on Executive Presence
From their interviews, Dagley and Gaskin (2014) identified 10 core characteristics that affect executive presence. They fall into two groups according to when observers judge them.
- Judged during initial contacts: status and reputation, physical appearance, projected confidence, communication ability and engagement skills.
- Judged over time: interpersonal integrity, values in action, intellect and expertise, outcome delivery ability and coercive power use.
The characteristics combine in different ways to form four archetypes, which the authors name positive presence, unexpected presence, unsustainable presence and dark presence. The authors conclude that executive presence is a complex construct, both in the breadth of characteristics behind it and in the influence of time on perceptions. For a leader, the practical point is that a first impression and the evaluation colleagues form over months are two separate things to manage.
How Quickly First Impressions Form
Research on impression formation explains why the first group of characteristics has so much weight. Ambady and Rosenthal (1993) showed strangers silent video clips of college teachers lasting under 30 seconds. Their judgments of the teachers' nonverbal behavior significantly predicted the evaluations that students gave at the end of the semester. In a second study, similar judgments predicted a principal's ratings of high school teachers. Ratings based on clips of 6 and 15 seconds were also strongly related to those outcomes.
An audience therefore forms a working impression within the first moments of a meeting or presentation, and much of it comes from nonverbal behavior. Preparation of an opening is time well spent.
Confidence Signals and Actual Competence
Observers often read confident behavior as a sign of ability. Anderson and Kilduff (2009) studied task groups and found that individuals higher in trait dominance were rated as more competent by fellow group members, by outside peer observers and by research staff, even after controlling for their actual abilities. Dominance predicted behaviors that signal competence, and those behaviors predicted peer ratings of competence.
Two consequences follow. People who evaluate others should treat assertive behavior as weak evidence of ability and look at results. People who are capable and reserved may be rated below their ability, so making reasoning and results visible is a legitimate part of developing presence.
Bias in Judgments of Executive Presence
Because executive presence is a perception, it can reflect bias as well as merit. In the Dagley and Gaskin (2014) study, the majority of the executives described as having presence were men. Role congruity theory offers an explanation. Eagly and Karau (2002) propose that a perceived mismatch between the female gender role and leadership roles leads to two forms of prejudice: women are perceived less favorably than men as potential leaders, and behavior that fits a leader role is evaluated less favorably when a woman enacts it. Hewlett's own work discusses how standards of presence can disadvantage women and people from underrepresented groups.
An organization that uses presence as a promotion criterion can reduce this risk by naming the specific behaviors it expects and by asking evaluators for examples.
Can Executive Presence Be Developed?
Evidence from research on charisma suggests that the way a leader comes across can change with training. Antonakis, Fenley and Liechti (2011) ran two studies. In a field experiment, 34 middle level managers were randomly assigned to a training group or a control group, and their coworkers rated them again three months later. In a laboratory experiment, 41 MBA participants gave a speech, received training, and gave the speech again 6 weeks later for 135 independent assessors. The training had significant effects on ratings of leader charisma (mean D = .62), and charisma had significant effects on ratings of leader prototypicality and emergence.
Charisma is a narrower concept than executive presence, and the study measured ratings from others over a period of weeks to months. Within those limits, it supports the view that presence related behavior can be learned.
How to Develop Executive Presence
- Find out how you come across. Presence is a perception, so start with information from other people: a trusted colleague, a coach, or 360 degree feedback.
- Prepare the opening. Impressions form early. Before an important meeting, decide your main point and your first sentences.
- State a position and your reasoning. Lead with the recommendation, then give the two or three reasons that matter most to this audience.
- Stay composed under pressure. When challenged, pause, restate the question and answer it directly. Confidence under pressure is the core of gravitas in Hewlett's account.
- Make competence visible. Share results and the reasoning behind them with the people who make decisions about your work. See the guide on being passed over for promotion.
- Build the record that people judge over time. Keep commitments, act on stated values and deliver results. These are the characteristics that sustain presence after the first impression.
Executive Presence Example
A finance director presents quarterly forecasts to the executive committee. Her analysis is rarely questioned, yet she has been told that she needs more executive presence. She asks three colleagues who attend those meetings what they observe. Their answers agree: she opens with several minutes of method, gives her recommendation last, and softens it when the chief executive pushes back.
With her coach she sets two goals. She will open each presentation with her recommendation in one sentence, and when challenged she will restate her position once with its main reason before discussing alternatives. After three committee meetings she asks the same colleagues what has changed.
Executive Presence and Political Skill
Political skill is defined by Ferris and colleagues as the ability to understand others at work and to use that knowledge to influence them toward personal and organizational objectives (Ferris et al., 2005). Research on political skill offers a more precise way to think about the same territory as executive presence. The dimension called apparent sincerity describes whether others see a person as genuine, and interpersonal influence describes the ability to adapt how one comes across to a given audience. Both can be assessed and developed. See the guides to political skill, the Political Skill Inventory and influence without authority.
How Pine Perspective Relates to Executive Presence
Pine Perspective measures what a leader can do. Its Influence Agility assessment covers three dimensions: Landscape Reading, Relationship Navigation and Projected Authenticity. In the Pine model, Projected Authenticity is the dimension closest to executive presence. It describes whether a leader comes across as credible and trustworthy while pursuing their goals.
The 360 degree feedback option combines the self assessment with anonymous feedback from up to 7 colleagues and shows how others perceive a leader's influence style compared with the leader's own view. It is available exclusively through certified Pine coaches. The method is described on the political skill assessment page, and the coach offering on the page for coaches.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is executive presence? Executive presence is the impression a leader makes on others that leads them to see that leader as credible, confident and ready for greater responsibility. It is a perception held by an audience, formed from how a person acts, speaks and appears, and revised by what that person does over time.
What are the three elements of executive presence? In the model described by Sylvia Ann Hewlett (2014), the three elements are gravitas, communication and appearance. Gravitas, which includes confidence under pressure and decisiveness, carries the most weight.
Can executive presence be learned? Research on charisma training suggests that it can. In two studies, training had significant effects on how coworkers and independent assessors rated leader charisma (Antonakis, Fenley, and Liechti, 2011).
Is executive presence the same as charisma? The two overlap, and executive presence is the broader term. The characteristics identified by Dagley and Gaskin (2014) include integrity, expertise and delivery of results, which observers judge over time.
How is executive presence assessed? Because it is a perception, the most direct evidence comes from other people. Structured feedback from colleagues, such as 360 degree feedback reviewed with a coach, shows how a leader comes across and where that differs from the leader's own view.
References
- Ambady, N., & Rosenthal, R. (1993). Half a minute: Predicting teacher evaluations from thin slices of nonverbal behavior and physical attractiveness. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 64(3), 431 to 441.
- Anderson, C., & Kilduff, G. J. (2009). Why do dominant personalities attain influence in face-to-face groups? The competence-signaling effects of trait dominance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 96(2), 491 to 503.
- Antonakis, J., Fenley, M., & Liechti, S. (2011). Can charisma be taught? Tests of two interventions. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 10(3), 374 to 396.
- Dagley, G. R., & Gaskin, C. J. (2014). Understanding executive presence: Perspectives of business professionals. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 66(3), 197 to 211.
- Eagly, A. H., & Karau, S. J. (2002). Role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders. Psychological Review, 109(3), 573 to 598.
- Ferris, G. R., Treadway, D. C., Kolodinsky, R. W., Hochwarter, W. A., Kacmar, C. J., Douglas, C., & Frink, D. D. (2005). Development and validation of the political skill inventory. Journal of Management, 31(1), 126 to 152.
- Hewlett, S. A. (2014). Executive Presence: The Missing Link Between Merit and Success. HarperBusiness.
Share this article

Founder & CEO, Pine Perspective
Andrea Gill is the Founder and CEO of Pine Perspective, specializing in influence agility and leadership development. With over a decade of experience at the intersection of organizational behavior, strategy, and ethics, she helps leaders develop the political skill their careers actually run on.
You might also like

360 Degree Feedback: Definition, Research and Conditions for Use
360 degree feedback compares a leader's self rating with anonymous ratings from manager, peers and direct reports. Definition, research and conditions.


Psychological Safety at Work: Definition, Research and Leader Practices
Psychological safety at work: Edmondson's definition, research on team learning and speaking up, signs of low safety, and how leaders build it.


DISC Styles and Influence at Work
How each DISC style (D, I, S, C) influences at work, its common blind spot, how to widen your range, and how to influence colleagues of each style.
